Pepperoni: The Ultimate Guide to America’s Favorite Pizza Topping

By: the PROs

Pepperoni: The Ultimate Guide to America’s Favorite Pizza Topping

Advertiser Disclosure

Today, we’re going to talk about one of the most popular pizza toppings out there – pepperoni!

This classic topping has been a staple in the hearts and taste buds of pizza lovers everywhere for decades. With its irresistible combination of spicy and savory flavors, it’s no wonder that pepperoni is one of the most requested toppings when ordering a pie.

So, whether you’re a fan of traditional pepperoni pizza or are looking for new ways to enjoy this tasty ingredient, join us as we dive into the world of pepperoni!

Find out what it is made of, how to store it, and how to know if it has gone bad.

So let’s get started!

Key Takeaways

Pepperoni

Making of Pepperoni:Pepperoni is a delicious meat product that is a staple in many households. It’s made by blending ground beef and ground pork and then seasoned with a mix of spices, including pepper, to give it that irresistible spicy kick.

Pepperoni in Everyday Use: The cooked pepperoni is sliced thin and is often used as a pizza topping, but it’s also available in supermarkets, packaged and ready for you to take home.

Why Choose Pepperoni?: With its mouth-watering flavor that’s both spicy and savory, it’s no wonder why pepperoni is so popular! Whether you’re a pizza lover or just enjoy a good meat and cheese snack, pepperoni is a must-try. If you haven’t already done so.

What is Pepperoni?

You might already know what pepperoni is but let us explain more about it.

Pepperoni is made from a mixture of cured beef and pork, seasoned with paprika, garlic, salt, and other spices. It is then dried, fermented, and often smoke-cured to develop its signature flavor and texture.

Pepperoni is usually thinly sliced and arranged in a circular pattern on top of a pizza before it’s baked. Pepperoni is a staple ingredient in American-style pizza and is one of the most popular pizza toppings in the United States.

Additionally, it can also be used as a topping for sandwiches, in salads, and as a snack on its own. Pepperoni adds a spicy, salty, and slightly smoky flavor to any dish it’s added to.

pepperoni slices
Pepperoni Slices

History of Pepperoni

The origin of pepperoni is a bit of a mystery, but it’s believed to have originated in the United States, most likely in the early 20th century introduced by Italian immigrants in the United States. The first use of “pepperoni” to refer to a sausage dates to 1919. Since then, it has rapidly grown in popularity and evolved into different types and variations.

Some food historians believe that pepperoni is an American invention of the spicy salami that Italian immigrants brought with them to the U.S.

The word “pepperoni” is derived from the Italian word “peperoni,” which means “bell peppers.”

However, it’s not clear if the word was used to describe the sausage in Italy or if it was a term that was invented in the U.S.

Regardless of its origins, pepperoni quickly became a popular topping for pizza in American pizzerias and remains so to this day.

In fact, it’s estimated that over 36% of all pizzas ordered in the U.S. include pepperoni.

What is Pepperoni Made Of?

Pepperoni is made with a combination of simple and flavorful ingredients including different seasonings and spices. The main ingredients in pepperoni include cured beef and pork, which are ground together and mixed with a blend of spices.

What Spices are in Pepperoni?

Some of the most common spices used to flavor pepperoni include paprika, garlic, salt, and black pepper. The mixture is then fermented, dried, and often smoke-cured, which helps to develop its signature flavor and texture.

Depending on the recipe, other ingredients such as sugar, red wine, or fennel seeds may be added to the mixture to enhance the flavor.

Why is Pepperoni Red?

Pepperoni is red in color because of the use of paprika or red pepper flakes in the seasoning mixture. Paprika is made from dried and ground red peppers, and it imparts a reddish color to the meat mixture.

Additionally, the curing process used to preserve the meat also contributes to its red color. During the curing process, nitrates are added to the meat mixture, which not only helps to preserve it but also reacts with the amino acids in the meat to form a red pigment. This combination of spices and curing results in the signature red color of pepperoni.

The ingredients used to make pepperoni are carefully chosen to create a delicious, spicy, and slightly smoky sausage that is perfect for adding a bold and satisfying flavor to any dish.

Pepperoni Ingredients

Here is a list of ingredients typically used to make pepperoni.

Pork

Spices and seasonings such as black pepper, red pepper, garlic, paprika, etc.

Water

Salt

Lactic acid (that acts as a starter culture)

Other acids used for preservation purposes

Sodium nitrate (added to cure the pork)

What Does Pepperoni Taste Like?

Pepperoni is made with a combination of simple and flavorful ingredients. The main ingredients in pepperoni include cured beef and pork, which are ground together and mixed with a blend of spices.

Some of the most common spices used to flavor pepperoni include paprika, garlic, salt, and black pepper. The mixture is then fermented, dried, and often smoke-cured, which helps to develop its signature flavor and texture.

Depending on the recipe, other ingredients such as sugar, red wine, or fennel seeds may be added to the mixture to enhance the flavor.

The ingredients used to make pepperoni are carefully chosen to create a delicious, spicy, and slightly smoky sausage that is perfect for adding a bold and satisfying flavor to any dish. Whether you’re making a pizza, a sandwich, or just snacking on a slice, pepperoni is sure to be a hit!

What Meat is in Pepperoni?

Pork is the meat that is usually used to make pepperoni, though a combination of pork and beef can also be used. Pepperoni is also sometimes made using turkey meat.

How is Pepperoni Made?

Pepperoni is made through a process that blends the flavors of cured beef and ground pork with a carefully chosen blend of spices. Here’s a general overview of the process:

  1. First, the meat (pork or pork + beef) is trimmed to remove fat. Then, the meat is ground and the lactic acid culture is added to it along with the spices and seasonings. Lactic acid bacteria are injected into the ground meat to lower the meat’s pH balance. Lowering the balance allows it to become better preserved for later consumption.  The bacteria present in lactic acid start the fermentation process, which takes some time. The ground meat is mixed with spices, including paprika, garlic, salt, and black pepper. Depending on the recipe, other ingredients such as sugar, red wine, or fennel seeds may be added to enhance the flavor.
  2. Next, the mixture is formed into large logs and left to ferment. This process allows the flavors to meld together and develop a tangy taste.
  3. After fermentation, the logs are then dried, which helps to concentrate the flavors and give the pepperoni its signature texture.
  4. Finally, the dried logs are moved to a drying room where they can stay for up to 20 days to be smoke-cured, which adds a smoky flavor and helps to further preserve the sausage.
  5. Once the curing process is complete, the pepperoni is ready to be sliced and enjoyed!

The process of making pepperoni involves a careful balance of ingredients, time, and techniques to create a delicious and irresistible sausage that is perfect for adding bold flavor to any dish.

pepperoni pizza

Types of Pepperoni

Pepperoni is a versatile and beloved ingredient that comes in many different varieties, each with its own unique flavor and texture. Here’s a brief overview of some of the most popular types of pepperoni:

Traditional Pepperoni

This is the most classic and well-known type of pepperoni. It has a slightly spicy and salty flavor, with a slightly smoky taste that comes from the smoke-curing process. This type of pepperoni is the most commonly used on pizzas and is loved for its bold flavor and tender texture.

Spicy Pepperoni

As the name suggests, spicy pepperoni is made with a blend of spices that are designed to add a little extra heat to your dish. This type of pepperoni is perfect for those who love a little extra spice in their food.

Uncured Pepperoni

Uncured pepperoni is a distinct variety of the beloved pizza topping that has been gaining popularity among those seeking more natural alternatives. Rather than using synthetic nitrates or nitrites in the curing process, uncured pepperoni leverages natural sources like celery powder or juice.

During the curing process, these natural sources react with specific bacteria to form nitrites, serving the same preservative and flavor-enhancing functions as their synthetic counterparts. The result is a pepperoni that maintains the robust, spicy flavor profiles we adore but offers a fresh perspective on a classic ingredient.

Though it’s sometimes marked by a slightly different color—a less vibrant red due to the natural curing agents—it’s a flavorful and versatile meat that’s as at home on a pizza as it is in a variety of other dishes.

Thick-sliced Pepperoni

Thick-sliced pepperoni is exactly what it sounds like – pepperoni that is sliced into larger pieces. This type of pepperoni is perfect for those who love a hearty and filling snack, as each slice provides a satisfying crunch and bold flavor.

Turkey Pepperoni

Turkey pepperoni is a healthier alternative to traditional pepperoni, as it is made with ground turkey instead of beef and pork. This type of pepperoni has a slightly milder flavor and a tender texture, making it a great option for those who are looking for a healthier alternative.

Beef Pepperoni

Beef pepperoni is a type of pepperoni that is made solely with ground beef. This type of pepperoni has a slightly different flavor than traditional pepperoni, as it has a bolder and more intense beef flavor. It’s perfect for those who love the taste of beef and want to add a little extra flavor to their dishes.

Regardless of which type of pepperoni you choose, they are all delicious and versatile ingredients that are perfect for adding bold flavor to any dish.

Old World Pepperoni

Old world pepperoni, a classic favorite, is known for its distinctive smoky, spicy, and slightly tangy flavor. It undergoes a traditional curing process where synthetic nitrates or nitrites are used to enhance flavor, maintain a vibrant red color, and extend the meat’s shelf life by inhibiting bacterial growth.

A hallmark of this style of pepperoni is that it often curls up into “cups” when cooked, which adds a unique texture and a slightly crispy edge to your pizza. Its rich, full-bodied flavor profile and satisfying texture have made old world pepperoni a timeless staple on pizzas and in a variety of dishes around the globe.

How to Use Pepperoni

Pepperoni is a versatile ingredient that can be used in a variety of dishes to add bold and satisfying flavor.

Here’s a brief overview of some of the most popular uses for pepperoni:

Pizza Toppings

Pepperoni is a classic pizza topping that adds a bold and spicy flavor to any pizza. It’s one of the most popular toppings in the United States and is loved for its tender texture and delicious flavor.

Sandwiches

Pepperoni is a great addition to sandwiches, as it adds a bold and salty flavor that pairs perfectly with cheese, vegetables, and sauces.

Snacks

Pepperoni can be enjoyed on its own as a delicious and satisfying snack.

Recipes

Pepperoni can be used in a variety of different recipes to add bold flavor and texture. Whether you’re making a pasta dish, a casserole, or a salad, pepperoni is a versatile ingredient that can be used in many different ways to enhance the flavor of your dish.

Pepperoni is a delicious and versatile ingredient that can be used in a variety of different dishes to add bold flavor and texture.

How Long Does Pepperoni Last?

If you’ve bought pepperoni and intend to use it as a topping the next time you make pizza, you might be wondering how long it can last if you store it.

According to the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), pepperoni that hasn’t been opened can be stored in your refrigerator for an indefinite period, or up to 6 weeks in your pantry.

Once you’ve opened the pepperoni and used some of it, you can safely store the rest in your fridge for up to 3 weeks, according to the USDA. Because it’s cured meat it really doesn’t need to be frozen—it will keep for a long time in the refrigerator.

How to Tell if Pepperoni Has Gone Bad

Not storing pepperoni properly can make it go bad. This mostly happens if you leave it out for too long at room temperature or store it incorrectly.

So how can you tell if pepperoni has gone bad and is unsafe to consume?

Here are two major indicators you need to watch out for:

Smell

If the pepperoni gives off a pungent, rancid odor, it is a clear indicator that it has gone bad. The bad smell is due to the fat in the pepperoni.

Appearance

If pepperoni has gone bad, it is likely to be soggy or slimy instead of dry. Moreover, the edges of the slices will look shriveled. One thing to keep in mind here is that you shouldn’t look for mold as a sole indicator for judging if pepperoni is okay to eat. Since pepperoni contains preservative acids, it’s unlikely mold will form in the first place.

Is Pepperoni Vegan?

Pepperoni made from pork or beef is, of course, not vegan since both of these meats are derived from animals. But that doesn’t mean vegetarians can’t enjoy pepperoni. While the majority of pepperoni produced in the US is non-vegan, vegan pepperoni also exists and is a good alternative to meat-based pepperoni.

Vegan pepperoni is something you should consider if you want to have the full vegan pizza experience. Vegan options for pepperoni are delicious and nearly similar in taste and flavor to their meat-based counterparts.

So, what exactly is vegan pepperoni and what ingredients is it made from?

It is made from plant-based ingredients such as tofu, vegetables, soy proteins, and wheat glutens. The ingredients used in making the base of the pepperoni can differ depending on the manufacturer, but vegan pepperoni has the same appearance and texture as that “real” pepperoni.

Is There an All-Beef Pepperoni?

As we explained before, pepperoni can be made from a few different types of meat such as pork, beef, and turkey. In most cases, many types of pepperonis are made from a combination of pork and beef.

So, is there an all-beef pepperoni? The answer is yes!

You can easily find a variety of all-beef pepperoni at your local grocery store from different manufacturers.

As the name suggests, all-beef pepperoni is made using only beef instead of pork or a combination of the two. All-beef pepperoni is perfect for those looking for “Halal” pepperoni (made without pork). Turkey pepperoni is more popular with those wanting to avoid red meat.

All-beef pepperoni isn’t very popular but it is easily and widely available across the US. Pork or pork + beef pepperoni is more popular than all-beef pepperoni in the country.

How to Store Pepperoni

Storing pepperoni properly is important if you intend to use it later. As we mentioned before, whole and unopened pepperoni can be stored in your refrigerator for as long as you like. But if you’re storing it in your pantry, then it’ll be good for up to 6 weeks. Pepperoni that is opened can be refrigerated for up to 3 weeks.

If you want to store pepperoni slices for later, either seal them up properly in the original packet or use air-tight bags to store them. If you want to store leftover pepperoni for a long period, you’ll need to freeze it in your freezer at 32 degrees Fahrenheit.

Storing Pepperoni

But freezing isn’t always good for pepperoni as it can affect its quality and taste. To prevent that from happening, it is always a good idea to check the manufacturer’s instructions on the package for storing pepperoni before you do anything.

If the instructions don’t recommend freezing, then avoid it and try refrigeration instead.

Best Pepperoni for Pizza

Many brands and manufacturers make great pepperoni that you can use as a topping for pizza and other dishes.

Here, we’ve rounded up some of the best pepperonis for pizza. Please note that the prices mentioned are the ones at the time of writing and may change.

Vermont Smoke & Cure Smoked Uncured Pepperoni (made with vegetarian-fed pork) (6 oz, $ 6.99)

Margherita Pepperoni Sticks (made with beef and pork) (4 sticks, 2 pounds, $ 32.99)

Bridgford Old World Pepperoni Stick (made with beef and pork) (1 stick, 1 pound, $ 14.00)

Battistoni Cup Char Spicy Pepperoni (made with beef and pork) (single 5 oz pouch, $ 9.40)

Vincenza’s Sliced Pepperoni (made with pork) (4 oz, $ 7.99)

What to Consider When Buying Pepperoni for Pizza

If you’re thinking of buying pepperoni slices as a topping for your upcoming homemade pizza project, there are some things you need to consider before you go out to buy them.

Here are some tips to help you out.

The Shape of Pepperoni Slices

Pepperoni slices are either shaped like a cup (curled at the edges) or completely flat. This totally depends on what you prefer and like.

Meat

Pepperoni slices can be made from different types of meats (beef, pork, or turkey). Again, the choice of meat and ingredients comes down to your preference.

Thickness

If you want your pepperoni slices to be nice and crunchy, go for thinner slices. Thicker slices aren’t as crunchy. This is only our opinion, and once again, it depends on what you prefer.

Here’s What the PROs at Homemade Pizza Pro Use and Recommend

Vermont Uncured Pepperoni

Here's a classic pepperoni that's a little bit smoky and a little bit spicy. The Uncured Smoked Pepperoni is made with fennel, paprika, and red pepper flakes, perfect for pizza, paired with a slice of cheese, or as a bright addition to spaghetti sauce.

From vegetarian-fed pork raised without antibiotics or added hormones. Made without sodium nitrate or preservatives. Gluten-free, nut-free, and dairy-free.

Check it Out
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you!

FAQs

Here, we answer some other questions you might have about pepperoni:

Is pepperoni with a high-fat content better? Or should it have a lower fat content?

Pepperoni which has a higher fat content tastes great. The greater the fat content, the better it will taste. But more fat also makes pepperoni less healthy, so you need to be careful about the fat content when you buy pepperoni.

Does pepperoni need to be cooked before it is put on the pizza?

It all comes down to personal preference. Some people prefer cooking the pepperoni before putting it on the pizza. Others choose to let it cook while the pizza is in the oven. There isn’t a right answer to this question. Choose the method that suits you best.

The Last Slice

Pepperoni is a beloved and versatile ingredient that is loved for its bold flavor and tender texture. With its rich history and various types and uses, pepperoni is a must-have ingredient in any kitchen.

Pepperoni is a popular meat product similar to spicy salamis that is widely consumed as a topping on pizza. There are some people who eat pepperoni every day. It is a type of spicy salami that is made from a mixture of beef and pork, seasoned with a blend of spices, including black pepper.

The cooked pepperoni is usually sliced thin and placed on top of a pizza before being baked. It can also be found in butcher shops or typical supermarkets in the same place where you can find hot dogs and sausages. It is used to stuff sandwiches and other dishes besides pizza.

The flavor of pepperoni is a perfect combination of spicy and savory, making it a popular choice for many cheese and meat lovers. While it is commonly associated with pizza, it can also be paired with other ingredients such as bell pepper, to create a variety of delicious meals.

Pepperoni is available in a variety of meats, shapes, and sizes. The most popular kind of pepperoni in the US is made from pork or a combination of pork and beef. It tastes great and adds flavor to your pizza.

Whether you’re making a classic pizza, a delicious sandwich, or a hearty snack, pepperoni is sure to add bold flavor and a satisfying taste to any dish.

So next time you’re looking for a delicious and versatile ingredient, be sure to reach for pepperoni!

We hope you enjoyed reading this guide on pepperoni and found answers to the questions you were looking for.

Thank you for reading and good luck on your journey to become the best pizza baker!

Enjoy!

Not a PRO? Not a Problem!

Take a pizza class to bring your pizza skills to the next level,

so you can be a PRO!

Baker's Percentage Charts for Pizza

Baker’s Percentage Charts for Pizza Dough: Unlock the Secret Formula for Perfect Pizzas Every Time!

the PROs

This baker’s percentage chart will give you a starting point to develop your own recipe.  These are the four main base recipes that can be adapted to any other pizza style. 

Costco Pizza Prices

Costco Pizza Price 2023 (Best Bang for Your Buck!)

the PROs

Costco Pizza Price 2023 Costco Pizza is one of the best options for finding delicious and affordable pizza. Its large …

how to mix pizza dough

How to Mix Pizza Dough

the PROs

How to Mix Pizza Dough Do you want to learn how to mix pizza dough? Pizza dough is a staple …

Check Out Our Pizza T-Shirts

Check Out Our Preferred Vendors

Newsletter

Subscribe to our Recipe of the Week newsletter and receive our partners’ latest recipes, tips, and discount offers.

Keep in Touch!

info@homemadepizzapro.com

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Table of Contents