Uncover the Best Kept Secrets of Costco Pizza: [PRO Tips, FAQs, and More]

By: the PROs

Uncover the Best Kept Secrets of Costco Pizza: [PRO Tips, FAQs, and More]

Advertiser Disclosure

Costco Pizza

We recently asked some loyal Costco shoppers what they loved the most about the retail giant – the answer was a tie between stealing prices and the delicious Costco pizza.

Were we amused to hear the majority’s answers – yes!

But were we surprised?

Big no!

After all, one expects such a response from a place that ranks as the 14th largest pizza chain in the country; it is a different story that many people don’t know the business sells pizza.

Even those who know about Costco pizzas don’t know everything about it!

But hey, what else are we here for? With 20+ FAQs, pro tips, and more, we have composed this article as the ultimate guide to Costco pizza.

So, let’s get started!

Key Takeaways

Costco Pizza

Costco food court offers two kinds of pizza: cheese and pepperoni. A slice of cheese or pepperoni pizza costs $1.99 and $9.95 for the whole pizza.

The combo pizza was discontinued, and it may be permanent.

You can only order Costco pizza in person at the food court or by phone, as Costco does not offer online ordering or delivery for pizza.

Ah, the infamous Costco Pizza. It’s a deliciously gooey and cheesy slice of heaven that will satisfy even the hungriest shoppers. But don’t just take our word for it; try it yourself! And the best part? You can even order ahead online for added convenience.

Sure, it’s not quite on par with a fancy New York Style Pizza from a sit-down joint, but let’s be real, who has the time or money for that when you’re a Costco member trying to feed your whole family on a budget?

Plus, with the option to order a pepperoni pizza or stick with the classic cheese, there’s something for everyone.

And let’s not forget about the crispy crust and generous portions. Unlike some other retailers, Costco isn’t skimping on the toppings or the slices.

And let’s be real, who doesn’t love a good deal?

The fact that Costco offers such high-quality pizza at such a low price is a testament to its overall business model and cost concerns.

But let’s not forget the Costco Food Court isn’t just about pizza. There are various menu offerings and other food items at unbeatable prices.

And let’s not forget, you must have a membership to shop at Costco, but let’s be real, it’s a small price to pay for the endless discounts and deals.

Let’s find out everything on the Costco pizza.

Costco Pizza

Costco pizza is a delicious and affordable staple of the American retail giant, Costco Wholesale Corporation. Renowned for its generous size and tantalizing toppings, this savory delight has become a beloved favorite among shoppers, who often treat themselves to a slice or two after a long day of bargain hunting.

With a choice of classic flavors like cheese, and pepperoni, Costco pizza has earned a devoted following for its unbeatable combination of taste, quality, and value, making it the perfect way to refuel and indulge during a shopping trip.

Costco Pizza Ingredients

Costco pizza ingredients are meticulously selected to ensure a consistently satisfying and high-quality product for their customers.

Costco Pizza Dough

The foundation of the pizza, the dough, is made from a blend of high-gluten and whole-grain flour combined with water, yeast, sugar, and salt. The dough rises, resulting in a fluffy and chewy crust.

Costco Pizza Sauce

Costco pizza tomato sauce is crafted from vine-ripened tomatoes and is seasoned with a blend of herbs and spices, including garlic, oregano, and basil, providing a rich and tangy base for the toppings.

The offerings include classic flavors such as cheese and pepperoni, which have remained on the menu after the regrettable discontinuation of the once-popular combo pizza. Despite reducing topping options, Costco pizza remains a sought-after treat for its unbeatable combination of taste, quality, and value. Customers continue to enjoy these delectable slices as a well-deserved reward after a day of bargain hunting, with the memory of the combo pizza lingering fondly in many’s minds.

Costco Cheese Pizza

The cheese pizza features a generous layer of whole-milk mozzarella, ensuring a gooey and flavorful experience with each bite. On the other hand, the pepperoni option includes savory slices of cured meat, adding a zesty and satisfying kick.

Costco Pepperoni Pizza

The Costco pepperoni pizza is a scrumptious and satisfying choice for those seeking a classic, flavorful option at the renowned retail giant. With a perfectly baked crust crafted from a blend of high-gluten and whole-grain flour, the pizza provides an ideal base for the tangy tomato sauce, seasoned with a harmonious mix of herbs and spices.

Generously topped with whole-milk mozzarella cheese and sixty mouthwatering slices of savory pepperoni, this pizza delights taste buds and fulfills cravings. As a testament to its quality, affordability, and taste, the Costco pepperoni pizza remains a fan favorite among shoppers, offering a well-deserved indulgence after a busy day of bargain hunting.

Costco’s commitment to responsibly sourcing and carefully preparing its ingredients ensures a delectable pizza experience that remains a beloved staple among shoppers.

Costco Pizza Size

Costco Pizza is well-known for its impressive size, setting it apart from many other pizzeria offerings. Each Costco pizza measures a substantial 18 inches in diameter, providing ample portions for sharing among family or friends. The generous size is visually impressive and contributes to the pizza’s overall value. The Costco pizza typically yields 12 large slices.

This makes Costco pizza an affordable and satisfying option for hungry shoppers or those seeking a convenient meal solution for gatherings or events. The substantial size of Costco pizza is a testament to Costco’s commitment to offering quality products at unbeatable prices and is a key factor in its enduring popularity among customers.

Costco Frozen Pizza

Costco’s frozen pizza selection provides customers with a convenient and tasty option for enjoying pizza at home. Found in the extensive freezer section of the retail giant, these frozen pizzas are available in various brands, flavors, and sizes, catering to a wide range of preferences. Popular choices include the Kirkland Signature brand, known for its quality ingredients and delicious taste, and other well-known pizza brands, each offering their unique take on classic pizza varieties.

The frozen pizzas typically come with an assortment of toppings, such as cheese, pepperoni, and sometimes more gourmet options like Margherita or BBQ chicken, ensuring there is something for everyone. Costco’s frozen pizzas are designed for easy preparation, requiring only a preheated oven and a few minutes of baking before they can be enjoyed.

The convenience of these frozen pizzas makes them a popular choice for busy families or those seeking a quick and satisfying meal option without sacrificing flavor. Costco’s commitment to quality and affordability is evident in its frozen pizza offerings, providing customers with a delectable and practical solution for their at-home pizza cravings.

Tips on Buying Costco Pizza

Costco’s food court is one of the many things that keeps members coming back, and their pizza is one of the best deals in the whole store. Whether you’re getting it by the slice or as a whole pie, it’s a deal that can’t be beaten.

No one likes ordering pizza the traditional way!

Placing an order for our favorite flavor and waiting for 45 minutes is too much hassle. As of right now, you cannot order Costco pizza online, unfortunately.

Luckily, some tips can help customers buy Costco pizza:

Costco-Cheese-Pizza-Slice
Costco Cheese Pizza

Call to Order Costco Pizza

The company claims speedy delivery, but let’s admit it: Costco favors members like parents favor the youngest child.

So, people who don’t have a Costco membership but don’t want to wait in line to get a pizza can call to place their orders.

However, the Costco pizza menu only facilitates call orders for entire pizzas, not single slices.

Order 30-minutes in Advance

Customers who call to place their Costco Pizza order ahead of time should call at least 30 minutes in advance.

The company guarantees quick service when customers order 15 minutes in advance. But there may be unexpected delays, so it’s best to call in advance!

Similarly, it is best to leave an hour of margin during rush hours.

Placing Pizza Order: The First Thing to Do At Costco

Another convenient way of receiving piping hot Costco Pizzas without waiting an hour in line is to arrange delivery later.

Customers can place their orders when they enter a Costco and ask the food court staff to “place it in the oven” by their desired time.

Leave the Pizza for Last!

Pizzas lose their freshness when customers pick them up from the food court and load their cars with their purchases afterward.

To get the best of both worlds, Costco Pizza lovers can place an order right before checking out, go back and pay for their purchases, load their cars and return just in time to pick up their hot pizza.

Costco Cheese Pizza
Costco Cheese Pizza

Costco Pizza FAQs


Does Costco Sell Unbaked Pizzas?

While Costco doesn’t sell uncooked, take-and-bake pizzas, customers can get pre-cooked pizzas at any Costco deli station and heat them in the microwave or oven before serving.

Additionally, customers can buy frozen pizza alternatives. Since these unbaked pizzas come with heating instructions, we suggest people go through them to get a perfectly cooked pie.

What Pizzas Are Available at Costco?

Costco Pizzas have three delicious flavors: pepperoni, cheese, and Combo (Temporarily Discontinued).

Cheese pizza is probably the most popular Costco food court item because they don’t use processed cheese. Instead, they only use fresh cheese.

The pepperoni pizza, on the other hand, contains 60 pepperoni slices.

The Combo consists of meat, cheese, and vegetables. It is a supreme pizza with all the ingredients from the pepperoni and cheese types. (The Supreme Costco pizza is temporarily out of the menu.)

Whether customers buy a whole pie or a single slice, they will benefit from quick service, regardless of the flavors.

How Much Do Costco Pizzas Cost?

Costco pizzas are incredibly cheap. The Costco food court sells 16″ to 18″ pizzas for $9.95 each. That is a lot cheaper than a pizza at Pizza Hut. And the best part is that they rarely increase their prices; the last time they raised them was in 1989!

On the other hand, individual Costco Pizza slices cost $1.99, less than a Starbucks Latte!

The cost of Costco pizzas remains the same throughout their 815 locations. Customers can get further discounts if they sign up for a $60 yearly membership.

How Much is a Costco Box of Pizza?

A four-pack frozen pepperoni pizza at Costco costs around $13.49. Customers can find these delicious delights in the store’s frozen foods section with other gluten-free and mini personal pizza boxes.

Can We Special Order Pizza at Costco?

Costco allows customers to customize their Costco Pizza from the food court. It takes roughly 10 to 15 minutes, resulting in a perfect pizza to meet their family’s needs.

Additionally, people can choose from pizza toppings, including red onions, black olives, Italian sausages, bell peppers, and mushrooms.

Do We Need to Order Costco Pizza Ahead of Time?

While it is not mandatory, calling out for pizza orders is valuable because customers have their orders ready when they arrive for pickup.

How Many Slices Are in a Whole Costco Pizza?

Costco Pizzas contains 12 delicious slices for six to eight pizza lovers. However, customers can ask for 8 or 16 slices.

A whole Costco pizza is divided into 12 slices, which means when you buy a whole pizza, each slice costs about $0.83.

If you want to buy one slice of pizza, you’ll be charged $1.99, which is quite affordable compared to other pizza chains.

However, $1.99 for one slice is more than double the price you would pay per slice if you ordered a whole pizza.

Why is Costco Pizza So Good?

Besides the fantastic price, customers find Costco Pizzas incredibly delicious because of their uniformity. They have refined their pizza-making process by using automated machinery to increase efficiency.

The store uses a “pizza robot” to spread an even layer of tomato sauce on the dough.

Additionally, the supermarket ensures that each pizza slice has the same amount of cheese, pepperoni, and other toppings.

Moreover, Costco uses an 80-20 blend of low-fat buttery mozzarella cheese and 10-month-aged shredded Parmesan in their cheese pizzas.

Did Costco Pizza Get Smaller?

Costco pizzas have been the same size for the past ten years and are larger than most pizza chains.

A large Costco Pizza is around 16″, while the same pizza from California Pizza Kitchen is around 14″.

How Long Does a Costco Pizza Take?

The Costco food court can be extremely crowded during peak hours, with ten or more people in lines not uncommon.

Even the most extensive lines move quickly, thanks to how fast the pizzas are prepared and baked. A dough ball transforms into a beautiful ready-to-bake pizza in under 30 seconds, thanks to automated procedures.

They use a dough squisher and pizza sauce turntable that roll the dough and evenly spread the sauce.

The staff then manually adds cheese and toppings, after which the pizza goes into a conveyer belt oven, which cooks for around six minutes.

Why Did Costco Stop Selling Take-and-Bake Pizzas?

Costco used to sell take-and-bake pizzas that customers could take home and bake for a nice lunch.

However, they stopped selling the product, although the customers can still buy frozen and fresh pizzas from the food court.

A Costco employee said, “Costco headquarters decided that [take-and-bake] pizzas weren’t worth it.”

What Size is a Costco Pizza?

Costco is the perfect pizza place for people who want humongous pizzas to satisfy their cravings.

Costco bakes larger pizzas than most famous pizzerias. Costco Pizzas are usually 16″ to 18″. Although Costco doesn’t sell small pizzas, customers can order as many individual slices as possible.

How Many Slices is a 16-inch Pizza?

A 16-inch Costco Pizza yields 12 slices. However, customers can request 8 or 16 slices as per their liking.

What is On Costco Combo Pizza?

The Costco Combo Pizza is similar to other pizzerias’ “supreme” flavors. It is topped with a traditional combination of onions, olives, pepperoni, bell peppers, mushrooms, and sausages. It is a combination of Costco Cheese and Costco Pepperoni Pizzas.

What is on a Costco Supreme Pizza?

A Costco Supreme Pizza is the same as a Costco Combo Pizza. So, it includes the same toppings like olives, pepperoni, bell peppers, mushrooms, and sausages.

Did Costco Stop Selling Combo Pizza?

Unfortunately, yes. The Combo pizza is one of the top 5 items removed from the Costco food courts menu that people miss the most.

In a Reddit conversation with a customer, a Costco staff member responded: “We realize your disappointment that the Combo Pizza is not available on our menu offering. Unfortunately, the Combo Pizza was withdrawn from our menu due to a difficult decision to simplify our business. We apologize for any inconvenience this has caused; these are not always simple decisions.”

Costco corporate cites profit and cost concerns, but they could’ve dealt with the issue easily via a price increase. Don’t you think?

Countless Costco members and membership families have sworn not to renew their membership with Costco due to this travesty. Fans of the combo pizza would have gladly paid the price to continue to enjoy it.

Is Costco Supreme Pizza Back?

Unfortunately, no! Many Costco members are disappointed that the combination of vegetables, pepperoni, and sausage on a large Costco pizza slice (or whole pie) is unavailable.

Does Costco Deliver Pizza?

The answer is again a no!

Costco does not deliver pizza or other food court items to customers’ homes.
Members can, however, purchase food court delights in person at the store. Customers can even place their orders ahead if they’re in a rush to save themselves from waiting in line.

There is a way to get around to having Costco pizza delivered. Check our article on Costco Pizza Delivery.

How Does Costco Put Sauce on Their Pizza?

Costco uses an automatic sauce dispenser that distributes tomato sauce evenly across the dough and the crust. This makes it easier for them to prepare pizzas in bulk efficiently.

More on Costco Pizza

Find how Costco makes it and much more!

The Last Slice


A trip to the warehouse retailer would be incomplete for many Costco members without a stop in the food court.

And what better to order at Costco than a piping hot pizza with crispy cheese and bubbling cheese?

Through this article, we shared our tips on ordering Costco Pizza with all the loyal Costco customers. Also, we answered some of the most frequent concerns, like why Costco’s combination pizza is discontinued.

Costco membership holders can always recreate the much-loved Costco Combo pizza. If they remember the taste and ingredients that went into the pizza, all that’s left for them to make their Costco-style Pizza is a good oven.

Our top recommendation here is the Ooni pizza oven. The portable outdoor pizza oven has a pizza stone with a perfect crispy crust.

Find Your Closest Costco Warehouse Location

Visit or phone your local Costco Food Court to place your pizza order.

Additional Costco Pizza Resources

Costco Pizza Prices

Costco Pizza Price 2023 (Best Bang for Your Buck!)

the PROs

Costco Pizza Price 2023 Costco Pizza is one of the best options for finding delicious and affordable pizza. Its large …

Costco Pizza Menu

Costco Pizza Menu in 2023 – No One Can Beat It!

the PROs

Costco Pizza Menu One of the reasons we enjoy going to the Costco food court so much is the Costco …

Costco Pizza Delivery

Costco Pizza Delivery: Find How You Can Get It Now!

the PROs

People go to Costco’s food court for many different reasons, but the cheesy slice of pizza they serve is among …

Costco pizza instructions

Costco Pizza Instructions: A Step-by-Step Process to the Best Pizza!

the PROs

Costco Pizza Instructions Costo is famous for its low prices and is also known for having the best-tasting pizza around …

Enjoy!

Not a PRO? Not a Problem!

Take a pizza class to bring your pizza skills to the next level,

so you can be a PRO!

Baker's Percentage Charts for Pizza

Baker’s Percentage Charts for Pizza Dough: Unlock the Secret Formula for Perfect Pizzas Every Time!

the PROs

This baker’s percentage chart will give you a starting point to develop your own recipe.  These are the four main base recipes that can be adapted to any other pizza style. 

Costco Pizza Prices

Costco Pizza Price 2023 (Best Bang for Your Buck!)

the PROs

Costco Pizza Price 2023 Costco Pizza is one of the best options for finding delicious and affordable pizza. Its large …

how to mix pizza dough

How to Mix Pizza Dough

the PROs

How to Mix Pizza Dough Do you want to learn how to mix pizza dough? Pizza dough is a staple …

Check Out Our Pizza T-Shirts

Check Out Our Preferred Vendors

Newsletter

Subscribe to our Recipe of the Week newsletter and receive our partners’ latest recipes, tips, and discount offers.

Keep in Touch!

info@homemadepizzapro.com

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Table of Contents