Plus: A Creative Tool to Make Your Own Pizza Topping Combination
Note: This post may contain affiliate links to products or services. When you press on the link, you may be redirected to our partner’s sites. If you buy any of their products or services, we may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. For more info see our Advertiser Disclosure.
Are you looking for the ideal pizza toppings list? Well, you don’t have to worry because we’ve got your back on this one!
The perfect pizza toppings come from a combination of your favorite ingredients. So not everyone is going to be on the same page.
For this reason, we will make a list of each type of pizza topping ingredient on a quest to find the perfect ingredients.
Besides, what is your favorite pizza combination? What does it contain?
Well, to find out more about everything to do with toppings, hang on with us.
Let’s get started!
Order of Pizza Toppings
We all start excellent when preparing the pizza dough, perfect garnishes, cheese, and sauce.
But, the problem comes when it’s time to combine all of them. Well, we have no type of indifference to people who have no standard order. But we are sure some Italians won’t be happy with the toppings coming in before the sauce.
Here is a standard order you could follow in coming up with the perfect homemade pizza.
PIZZA TOPPINGS LIST
List of Pizza Sauces
Sauces are essential in pizza preparation for their thick nature prevents sogginess in your meal. Incorporation of the dough with tomato garlic pizza sauce allows them to cook to a crisp simultaneously.
The garlic sheds its pungent punch upon cooking and adopts a sweet, savory taste that warms the mouth. Ranch flavored sauce is perfect for lovers of sour-tasting foods since the buttermilk introduces the tangy taste of sour cream, thus giving the sauciest raunchiest pizza ever.
List of Cheeses for Pizza
Getting cheesy with your pizza results in a melty and stringy pizza to desire after the clean plate.
Mozzarella, for instance, produces shreddable pizzas with a golden brown layering. Its health benefits are an added benefit since the carbs consumed in the pizza require healthy backup options.
When picking cheese for your pizza, factors include the type and moisture content. For example:
- Soft cheese like Mozzarella has 50 to 80 % moisture
- Cheddar is a hard cheese with a 40% moisture content
- Semi-hard cheese options like Parmesan stand at 34%
Check out our comprehensive list of cheeses for pizza for more.
List of Meats for Pizza
The meatier the pizza, the more appealing it is to the eye. Pepperoni toppings are an all-time classic with their thin slicings covering the top of a nicely cooked flatbread.
The uniformity it forms around a round or triangular slice compliments the chewy textural taste, especially on crispy pizza. Sausage toppings can be prepared versatilely by dicing the rolls, crumbling the sausage meat up from its casing, or making long thin stripes to spread on your dough.
Mats add to the crispiness of the meal, and the juicy crunches magnify the experience. Buffalo chicken goes well with the ranch-flavored sauces and dressings since you can always use more ranch condiments to cross the cravings.
List of Seafood for Pizza
Need a break from all the beef and chicken layered on your pizza? The Italians almost predominantly pick anchovies over all other seafood options.
The tiny fish bring a flavor combination ranging from savory to salty. Their nutritional health benefits with the provision of Omega 3 fatty oils, magnesium, zinc, and proteins make it the ultimate seafood topping for your pizza.
Anchovy pizza recipes are pretty easy to make, and if you pair them with the right wine, you’ll celebrate.
List of Veggies for Pizza
Most vegetables marry well with pizzas alongside making them look colorful and desirable. There are fewer calories incurred in the body with these toppings instead of the meaty and saucy options.
Green peppers and red onions are universally used vegetable toppings. You do not have to pre-cook your vegetable toppings since their cooking time matches that of the pizza.
However, if you are using mushrooms, they should always be pre-cooked due to their high moisture content.
Also, chewier vegetable options like broccoli can be blanched beforehand to ease their tough nature.
For additional flavor, pan sautee your onions till they are caramelized before placing them on your pizza. Uncooked onions often contain excessive moisture and may cook unevenly once directly placed on raw dough.
Are You Still Baking Pizzas in Your Kitchen Oven?
You Might Regret It, Don’t Miss Out!
Are you up for trying something new?
Go from a soggy pizza to the perfect pizza! How? With an Ooni pizza oven.
You might be thinking, a what?
With an Ooni pizza oven, you can bake your pizza in as little as 90 seconds.
They are not only affordable but you can take them anywhere.
Let’s check them out, you won’t be disappointed!
List of Fruits for Pizza
Fruits such as pineapples are used in the “controversial” Hawaiian pizza as healthy alternative toppings. For a meatier consistency and intense flavor, use figs and incorporate them with pungent cheese such as prosciutto and creamy goat cheese.
List of Herbs & Spices for Pizza
Spices generally give the pizza dough a minty and savory taste. Basil and oregano are the most common herbs and spice families for pizza toppings.
Mix different herbs and spices into your dough, such as mint, thyme, and fennel seeds, especially compliment pizza with pepperoni or spinach and brussel sprouts.
Rosemary should be carefully used since it is a solid and overpowering ability over other ingredients. Incorporating it in the sauce-making process is advisable instead of spreading it at the top.
Use peppers and black pepper as your garnish when going for a piney woody taste depending on your pizzas theme when you do have one.
List of Nuts & Seeds for Pizza
Nutty pizzas are jammed with flavors, especially when roasted nuts are the ingredient. They are healthy snack options since cashews, almonds, and pumpkin seeds are highly nutritious.
When using roasted nuts, ensure that they are entirely relaxed to evenly dry and not a soggy pizza-also, purpose to achieve an equal nut-to-marinade ratio.
This type of pizza is a vegan, gluten-free option.
List of Garnishes for Pizza
Garnishes are what are going to bring color to your pizza. Green is the most predominant color to use when garnishing pizza when using cilantro or parsley.
Red, orange and yellow are also common colors that you can use by using peppers like Thai chili peppers or roasted red peppers.
You can also bring black into the pizza game, by using garnishes like black salt, truffles, and caviar. Your budget will be the limit!
Popular Pizza Topping Combinations
Are you trying to impress your loved one? Try adding fine cheese and pepperoni. The combinations include pizza sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella, and any other cheese of your choice. It can be simple, but it is a win!
Pepperoni? More, please! The supreme contains pepperoni, peppers, pizza sauce, mozzarella, sausage, olives, mushrooms, and bacon.
Don’t be one of those people without trying the homemade Hawaiian. The combination is pineapple, ham, pizza sauce, mozzarella, and other sauce.
BBQ is the ultimate combination of meat for meat lovers. It contains bacon, pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef mince, and BBQ sauce.
Are you trying to find your Italian side? Italians love the blend of Buffalo mozzarella, pizza sauce, salt, and olive oil. Margherita will be your unique pizza combination once you try it.
Top 10 Pizza Toppings for 2022
According to research, Americans love their pepperoni pizza. We disagree on many things, but 53% of the pizza-eating population say pepperoni is our favorite.
So, if you are looking for an inclusive topping, you can try pepperoni. Both your friends and family will enjoy pepperoni because of the tangy, spicy, and rich taste. Pepperoni will pair well with plain cheese or any other vegetable.
Mushrooms are becoming one of the most popular toppings worldwide. These fungi are healthy for our bodies because they contain fiber, minerals, iron, and proteins. That is because both vegans and meat lovers can enjoy it.
Mushrooms have low calories, and their subtle earthy taste allows people to pair them with any other topping. Let’s not forget how it contributes to the overall presentation of your pizza.
Are you looking for a vegetable with a savory taste? Jolt down on the onions on your shopping list at this moment!
Besides the taste, you get that crunchiness and juicy onion taste that breaks the monotony of the cheese taste.
Many people love onions on their pizza because it is versatile, and you can pair them with any of your ingredients. The distinct color and onion shape will make your pizza look more attractive.
We could not agree more on the sausage toppings. Some of the typical sausage flavors include spicy sausages, beef, pork, chicken, salami, and the rest of the 200 varieties.
The good thing about the sausage is that you can also pair it with other meaty or vegetable toppings. You can choose to add different types and flavors to spice up your pizza, and hopefully, your pizza game too!
Are you looking to play it safe with the hope that your family will love your pizza? Bacon is the key if no one in your family is vegetarian. The salty and crunchy taste will pair well with anything.
Pair it with any cheese, vegetable, or any other meat and get the parent of the year award. If bacon soup, ice cream, and bacon soda exist, what could go wrong on your end?
- Extra Cheese
Yes! Extra cheese is also a topping. Forget the regular mozzarella. Even though it could work, we have many types of cheese that could contribute to the pizza’s taste and presentation.
Who doesn’t enjoy the extra gooey, thick, and stringy vibe that the pizza gives when you take a bite? If that is what you will do, add measurement to your recipe.
As we have heard above, there are many types of cheese with mild, sharp, nutty, smooth, buttery, smoky, sweet, meaty, and creamy flavors. Find your favorite cheese and treat yourself to a homemade pizza.
- Black Olives
Black olives are diverse! They have a mild, subtle salty flavor that makes them possible to pair with other ingredients.
You can pair black olives with garlic, parmesan, feta, tomato, onions, meat, and mushrooms, and people will love your pizza.
Sliced black olives also accent your pizza’s color, making it stand out.
- Green Pepper
We all know that red and yellow bell peppers are sweet, unlike the mildly bitter green peppers.
But today, we can assure you that you will love the zingy, crunchy, and rich flavor and aroma that the green peppers contribute to your pizza. The green color also eliminates the dullness of the pizza.
First of all, we come in peace talking about pineapple as a topping. Let’s not start a war on why pineapple made it to the list, but some people love the warm, juicy, and rich taste.
Pineapples can make great standalone toppings or pair well with other ingredients.
Still, we are open to critiques that say otherwise.
All jokes aside, we agree that pineapples are colorful and contribute to the presentation. If you are a family of pineapple lovers, go ahead and add some to your pizza.
There are no laws in the US that prohibit it.
Spinach on pizza? When cooked right, pizza can make up for all the past cooking shenanigans that your family has experienced.
The green color stands out from the other toppings and contributes to the presentation. Some people will not like the thought of a vegetable on their pizza, but after realizing it has no taste, it can change their minds.
The good thing is that you can add it raw or pre-cooked, and it will still contribute to the body’s nutritional value.
What Are Some Unusual Pizza Toppings?
You have probably tasted most, if not all, of the most common pizza toppings. Why don’t you try some unusual toppings if you make a homemade pizza? You might end up liking them. Pick one of the following combinations:
Do you always order calamari at your favorite restaurant? Why don’t you try it on your pizza too? Since people, we can confirm spinach is one of the people’s favorite toppings. Baby spinach, cheese, and aioli sauce can never go wrong.
Chicken Tikka Masala
If chicken is your favorite, you will love the mild spice and the thick buttery sauce as your topping.
Apple Honey BBQ Sauce, Basil, and Rhubarb
The Apple honey BBQ sauce and Rhubarb will give you a tasty savory flavor. Besides, the combination is not complete without basil’s mild, earthy taste.
Red Peanut Curry
This recipe should be one of your best choices. Imagine biting into cooked chicken dipped in red peanut curry and fresh basil leaves. That combination will have you craving more. The good thing is that you can also use beef, prawns, pork, or any other protein if you don’t like chicken.
Sausage, Jalapeno, Sriracha Sauce, and Bacon
Are you looking for something spicy? If you’re a meat lover, you will love this combination.
Homemade Pizza Toppings
You can get your favorite topping at your local store to add to your homemade pizza.
But the trick is to keep it simple. Some of the homemade combinations you should consider are:
- Sausage and kale
- Cheese and Garlic Pizza: mozzarella, garlic sauce, and oregano.
- Rosemary and Potato – Extra virgin olive oil, fresh rosemary, potato, and mozzarella
- Gorgonzola and mushroom
- Sliced pancetta, sliced fresh tomatoes, and rocket
- Capers, anchovies, and black olives
Tips to Make your Homemade Pizza Tastier
- Don’t buy pre-shredded mozzarella cheese. Shred your cheese.
- Choose a few pizza toppings. It won’t be easy to cook many pizza toppings.
- Follow the order of layering your pizza as we have mentioned above.
- Use good quality canned tomatoes for making your homemade sauce.
- Avoid making the pizza soggy. It would be best to drain the pineapple before putting it on the pizza and pre-cook vegetables like spinach or mushrooms.
How Many Pizza Toppings per Pizza?
We recommend you add no more than 5 toppings per pizza, that’s excluding the sauce and cheese. A pizza should always have a kind of sauce and cheese, so we are not counting them as toppings for these purposes.
Keep in mind, toppings can add a lot of moisture and weight to the crust. The more toppings you have the more difficult is to cook the pizza thoroughly. You want to evenly distribute the toppings throughout the entire pizza.
Pizza Toppings: How Much?
If you are wondering how much of each topping you should add to your pizza, here’s a reference guide per pizza size.
Recommended Amounts of Pizza Toppings
|Pizza Size||Sauce||Cheese||Pepperoni||Meats||Vegetables||Top Cheese|
|Personal 7″||1.5oz||2oz||8 Slices||2oz||1 – 2oz||.5oz|
|Small 10″||2oz||3oz||16 Slices||3oz||2 – 3oz||1oz|
|Medium 12″||4oz||6oz||20 Slices||4oz||3 – 5oz||1oz|
|Large 14″||5oz||8oz||32 Slices||5oz||5 – 7oz||1oz|
|X-Large 16″||6oz||10oz||40 Slices||6oz||6 – 10oz||2oz|
IMPORTANT: For purposes of determining the weight of toppings, if you are adding multiple toppings then the amount of topping should be the total weight of the toppings combined.
For example, if you are adding pepperoni and meat to a large pizza, then the combined weight of the two toppings should be no more than 5oz.
You can also, play it by ear, or in this case by your eyes. The toppings must make sense and you can always judge if you have too many or too few toppings.
What is the Perfect Pizza Topping Combination?
Creating the perfect pizza topping combination is entirely up to you and your personal preferences. You do want to create balance and cohesiveness among the pizza toppings you use. Every single topping will serve a purpose in achieving your flavor profile, which could be either saltiness or sweetness, etc.
For example, if you want to create an umami flavor profile, then your toppings should be those that complement each other to create the specific flavor.
The sky is the limit!
Pizza Flavor Profiles
When deciding which kind of pizza topping combination you want to make you can choose from the following pizza flavor profiles:
- Savory (Salty)
- Crunchy (Texture)
How to Create the Perfect Pizza Topping Combination
- Decide on the flavor profile you want to accomplish
- Make a list of ingredients or toppings that fit into that profile
- Choose the toppings according to your preference
The Last Slice
Now that you know how to order your pizza toppings, you have a list of pizza toppings, know some popular combinations, and choose your favorite ingredient.
We hope you also understood some of the tips on making a homemade pizza.
Besides, you can pick the homemade combination or the unusual one if you find it hard to determine your best ingredient. For this reason, it is time to start preparing your pizza toppings and be the best baker among your family and friends.
Do You Want to Create Your Homemade Pizza Recipe?
Easy! Fill out the form below, with your recipe details and we’ll send it to you!
Choose from your favorite ingredients, your unique toppings combinations, then share it with your friends and family!
Let us know how you did, we would love to know.
My Homemade Pizza Recipe
If you want any additional toppings added to the form, contact us, we will be glad to add anything you need. Your inspiration is our motivation!
Here are our recommended baker’s percentages per pizza style to help you create your recipe.
Not a PRO? Not a Problem!
Take a pizza class to bring your pizza skills to the next level,
so you can be a PRO!
Check Out Our Pizza T-Shirts
Check Out Our Preferred Vendors
Subscribe to our Recipe of the Week newsletter and receive the latest recipes, tips, and discount offers from our partners.
Keep in Touch!