Weirdest Pizza Toppings: Exploring the World One Slice at a Time

By: the PROs

Weirdest Pizza Toppings: Exploring the World One Slice at a Time

Check Out Our 60+ Weird Toppings List

Advertiser Disclosure

Have you ever pondered what might be the weirdest pizza toppings ever to grace the perfectly kneaded canvas of a pizza crust? Beyond the typical boundaries of pepperoni and mushrooms, there’s a culinary world bursting with offbeat and downright weird pizza toppings that will stir your curiosity, if not your appetite.

Imagine substituting your usual cheese for camel milk cheese or drizzling honey over your pizza instead of tomato sauce. Or how about a smattering of crispy insects or creamy durian on your pie?

Sounds weird?

Believe it or not, these are toppings that adorn pizzas on this eclectic gastronomical planet.

If you’re intrigued, you’re in the right place! It’s time to embark on a whirlwind culinary adventure that will introduce you to a whole new world of pizza possibilities. So buckle up as we take you on an enticing journey through the world’s weirdest, wackiest, and, against all odds, tastiest pizza toppings.

Keep reading; you might just discover your next favorite topping!

Let’s get started!

Pizza – the universally beloved culinary wonder – is no stranger to experimentation. Born in Naples, Italy, it has since been adopted and adapted by cultures worldwide, each adding their unique twist to this delectable staple. Traditional pizza typically features a yeasty flatbread topped with tomato sauce and cheese, embellished with various meats, vegetables, and condiments.

However, this post isn’t about your standard Margherita or Pepperoni feast. Instead, we’re veering off the beaten track, delving deep into the realm of the unconventional, exploring a world where pizza toppings aren’t just ingredients but a medium of culinary expression.

Unheard-of Pizza Toppings

When we think of pizza toppings, our minds automatically drift towards the familiar – a symphony of tomato, mozzarella, pepperoni, bell peppers, olives, or perhaps the polarizing pineapple. But what happens when we trade the security of the known for the thrill of the unknown?

What if we pushed the envelope, daring to top our pizza with ingredients that would make the traditionalist’s jaw drop?

Believe it or not, there’s a whole world of weird and wonderful pizza toppings out there, waiting to be discovered by those brave enough to take the leap. From the delicacies of the ocean to the fruits of the forest, from sweet to savory, and everything in between, pizza, it seems, is a universal canvas waiting for a sprinkle of culinary creativity.

It’s time to roll up our sleeves, open our minds (and our mouths), and plunge headfirst into the fascinating world of weird pizza toppings. Ready for the ride? Let’s dive in!

Brief History of Pizza

Our love affair with pizza began in Naples, Italy, in the late 18th and early 19th century. Initially, it was a dish for the poor, a simple and inexpensive fare made with readily available ingredients.

Traditional toppings consisted of tomatoes, garlic, cheese, and anchovies. As pizza’s popularity spread throughout Europe and eventually across the Atlantic to America, its toppings evolved as well, reflecting the culinary preferences of each region.

Pizza’s history has always been a testament to culinary adaptability and cultural exchange, from introducing pepperoni in America to using seafood in coastal areas and various vegetables in Mediterranean countries. But, even as we honor the traditions of this beloved dish’s traditions, an untamed frontier of unconventional toppings is waiting to be explored.

Exploring the Weirdest Pizza Toppings

As global palates have expanded and culinary borders have blurred, the uncharted territory of unconventional pizza toppings has opened up. From the tame and mildly strange to the truly bizarre, these unexpected toppings testify to human creativity in the kitchen.

They speak volumes about local produce, cultural delicacies, and regional predilections, turning each pizza pie into a flavorful snapshot of the region it originates from. In many ways, these outlandish toppings are culinary ambassadors, inviting us to embrace the diversity of world cuisines.

The notion of unconventional toppings isn’t just about shock value; it’s about exploration, understanding, and embracing the world’s diverse food culture through a medium we all know and love – pizza. It’s an invitation to venture outside our comfort zones, push our taste buds into new territories, and discover a world of flavor combinations we might not have considered.

After all, the world is full of strange and wonderful ingredients that can bring a new dimension to our beloved pizza.

Criteria for Selecting the Weirdest Pizza Toppings in the World

Several factors come into play when curating a list of the weirdest pizza toppings. First and foremost, the criteria hinge on unusual ingredients.

Unusual Ingredients

These toppings deviate drastically from the traditional roster you might find in your local pizzeria. They could be anything from unconventional meats (like kangaroo or alligator) to less common fruits, vegetables, or even insects. However, what is considered ‘unusual’ or ‘weird’ largely depends on geographical location and cultural context.

Unique Flavor Combinations

Secondly, unique flavor combinations play a significant role. These are instances where two or more ingredients, which wouldn’t typically be paired together, are combined atop a pizza.

The combination of sweet and savory, such as the Swedish banana and curry pizza, is a prime example of this category. These toppings challenge conventional wisdom about what ‘works’ on a pizza, offering an unexpected harmony of flavors that intrigues the taste buds.

Regional or Cultural Influences

Lastly, regional or cultural influences are crucial to weird pizza toppings. These weirdest pizza toppings reflect a country or region’s culinary traditions, local produce, or cultural preferences, often seeming eccentric to outsiders.

Consider the durian pizza in Southeast Asia or the pizza topped with haggis in Scotland. While commonplace in their respective regions, these weird toppings can seem outlandishly strange to those unaccustomed to these culinary traditions.

But in the name of pizza adventure, they certainly merit a try. After all, weirdness, much like beauty, is often in the eye (or palate) of the beholder!

weird pizza toppings infographic

Around the World in Pizza Toppings

Different cultures have adopted the pizza and infused it with their local flavors, creating unique and sometimes peculiar combinations that leave the world intrigued and, on occasion, aghast.

North America

North America isn’t shy when it comes to experimenting with pizza toppings. From the exotic alligator sausage in Louisiana to the sweet and savory Canadian bacon and apple pizza in the North, let’s not forget the comfort-food-inspired mac and cheese pizza that has found popularity across the United States.

Europe

Europe, the birthplace of pizza, hasn’t shied away from adding its own eccentric spin. Sweden, for instance, is known for its Banana Curry pizza, a peculiar blend of bananas, curry powder, and traditional pizza ingredients. A reindeer pizza, locally known as “Pizza Berlusconi,” is quite the rage in Finland.

Asia

Asia’s wide range of flavors and ingredients leads to some truly unique pizzas. Japan’s eel pizza and South Korea’s sweet potato pizza both push the boundaries of traditional pizza norms. And for the truly adventurous, there’s the durian pizza in China and Singapore, taking the ‘king of fruits’ from the streetside stalls to the pizza parlors.

South America

South American pizzas reflect their rich culinary culture and locally available produce. Brazil’s green peas topping and Argentina’s ‘Fugazzeta,’ a cheese and onion pizza, might seem unconventional but are delicious nods to the region’s produce and culinary styles.

Oceania

Australia and New Zealand are not behind in this race of odd toppings, with pizzas featuring kangaroo and emu meats in Australia, while New Zealand’s pizzas often include local shellfish.

Africa

In Africa, particularly in countries like Morocco and Algeria, pizzas are often topped with ingredients reflective of their vibrant food cultures – think spiced lamb or the camel milk cheese that offers a local twist to the classic cheese topping.

As we can see, the concept of ‘unusual’ is quite relative when it comes to pizza toppings. What may seem odd to one may be another’s comfort food. It’s a testament to pizza’s versatility and the culinary creativity of pizza lovers worldwide.

Weirdest Pizza Toppings from Around the World

Weird Toppings List:

  1. Bananas and curry: Sweet bananas and spicy curry sauce. Make by spreading curry sauce on pizza dough, adding sliced bananas, and baking.
  2. Alligator: Particularly popular in Louisiana, alligator meat is often used as a topping on pizza, offering a unique flavor that’s a cross between chicken and fish.
  3. Sweet Potato: A common topping in South Korea, sweet potato adds a unique sweet element to the savory dish.
  4. Kangaroo and Emu meat: Lean, gamey red meat. Make by grilling or pan-searing kangaroo meat, then adding it to pizza with your choice of toppings.
  5. Haggis and black pudding: Traditional Scottish ingredients. Make by cooking haggis and black pudding, then adding them to pizza with cheese and tomato sauce.
  6. Strawberries and balsamic vinegar: Sweet strawberries and tangy balsamic glaze. Make by adding sliced strawberries to pizza, baking, and drizzling with balsamic glaze.
  7. Sushi-inspired toppings: Raw fish, seaweed, and wasabi. Add sushi-grade fish, nori sheets, and a dollop of wasabi to pizza with cheese.
  8. Peanut butter and jelly: Creamy peanut butter and sweet jelly. Make by spreading peanut butter and jelly on pizza dough, adding cheese, and baking.
  9. Escargot (snails): Cooked snails with garlic and herbs. Make by sautéing snails in garlic and herbs, then adding them to pizza with cheese.
  10. Durian fruit: Pungent, tropical fruit. Make by removing durian flesh from the rind, adding it to pizza with cheese, and baking.
  11. Pickles and ice cream: Tangy pickles and sweet ice cream. Make by adding sliced pickles to pizza, baking, and topping with a scoop of ice cream.
  12. Chocolate and marshmallows: Rich chocolate sauce and gooey marshmallows. Make by spreading chocolate sauce on pizza dough, adding marshmallows, and baking.
  13. Reindeer meat: Gamey, Nordic meat. Make by cooking reindeer meat, then adding it to pizza with cheese and desired sauce.
  14. Macaroni and cheese: Creamy, cheesy pasta. Make by preparing macaroni and cheese, then adding it to pizza with extra cheese and baking.
  15. Popcorn and caramel: Fresh popcorn and caramel drizzle. Add cooked popcorn to the pizza, bake, and drizzle with caramel sauce.
  16. Fried insects (e.g., crickets, grasshoppers): Crunchy, protein-packed topping. Make by frying insects, then adding them to pizza with cheese and desired sauce.
  17. Octopus and squid ink: Tender octopus and black squid ink sauce. Make by cooking octopus, adding it to pizza with squid ink sauce and cheese, and baking.
  18. Vegemite and cheese: Salty, savory Australian spread. Make by spreading Vegemite on pizza dough, adding cheese, and baking.
  19. Spam and pineapple: Canned meat and sweet pineapple. Make by frying Spam slices, then adding them to pizza with pineapple, cheese, and sauce.
  20. Caviar and cream cheese: Luxurious fish eggs and smooth cream cheese. Make by spreading cream cheese on pizza dough, adding caviar, and baking.
  21. Green peas and mayonnaise: Creamy, veggie-packed topping. Mix green peas and mayonnaise, spread it on pizza dough, add cheese and bake.
  22. Hot dogs and mustard: American classic with hot dogs and tangy mustard. Make by slicing hot dogs, adding them to pizza with cheese, and drizzling with mustard before baking. 23. Oysters Rockefeller: Fresh oysters, spinach, and butter sauce. Make by preparing oysters Rockefeller, adding them to pizza dough with cheese, and baking.
  23. Breakfast pizza: Scrambled eggs, bacon, and hash browns. Make by topping pizza dough with cooked scrambled eggs, bacon, hash browns, and cheese, then baking.
  24. Fruit cocktail: Canned fruit medley. Make by draining canned fruit, adding it to pizza dough with cheese, and baking. Optionally, drizzle with honey or syrup.
  25. Lobster and truffle oil: Tender lobster and aromatic truffle oil. Make by cooking lobster, adding it to pizza with cheese, and drizzling it with truffle oil before baking.
  26. Fried chicken and waffles: Crispy fried chicken and mini waffles. Make by placing cooked fried chicken and waffles on pizza dough with cheese, then baking.
  27. Cotton candy and sprinkles: Fluffy cotton candy and colorful sprinkles. Make by baking pizza dough with cheese, then topping it with cotton candy and sprinkles.
  28. Marmite and avocado: Strong Marmite and creamy avocado. Make by spreading Marmite on pizza dough, adding sliced avocado and cheese, then baking.
  29. Smoked salmon and capers: Smoked salmon and tangy capers. Make by placing smoked salmon and capers on pizza dough with cheese and desired sauce, then baking.
  30. Grilled watermelon and feta cheese: Sweet grilled watermelon and salty feta. Make by grilling watermelon slices, adding them to pizza with feta and cheese, then baking.
  31. Tandoori chicken and mango chutney: Spicy chicken and sweet chutney. Make by placing the cooked tandoori chicken on pizza dough with cheese, then baking and topping with mango chutney.
  32. Brie cheese and pear: Creamy Brie and sweet pears. Make by placing Brie cheese and sliced pears on pizza dough, then baking.
  33. Kimchi and bulgogi: Spicy fermented cabbage and marinated beef. Make by adding cooked bulgogi and kimchi to pizza dough with cheese, then baking.
  34. Peking duck and hoisin sauce: Roasted duck and sweet-savory hoisin. Make by placing sliced Peking duck on pizza dough with cheese, then baking and drizzling with hoisin sauce.
  35. Caramelized onions and blue cheese: Sweet onions and pungent blue cheese. Make by adding caramelized onions and blue cheese to pizza dough, then baking.
  36. Pistachio and honey: Crushed pistachios and honey drizzle. Make by adding crushed pistachios to pizza dough with cheese, then baking and drizzling with honey.
  37. Shrimp and grits: Seasoned shrimp and creamy grits. Make by adding cooked shrimp and grits to pizza dough with cheese, then baking.
  38. Beetroot and goat cheese: Roasted beetroot and tangy goat cheese. Add cooked beetroot slices to pizza dough with goat cheese, then bake.
  39. Fig and prosciutto: Sweet figs and salty prosciutto. Make by placing sliced figs and prosciutto on pizza dough with cheese, then baking.
  40. Hummus and falafel: Creamy hummus and crispy falafel. Make by spreading hummus on pizza dough, adding cooked falafel pieces and cheese, then baking.
  41. Pastrami and sauerkraut: Thinly sliced pastrami and tangy sauerkraut. Make by adding pastrami and sauerkraut to pizza dough with cheese, then baking.
  42. Taco pizza: Seasoned ground beef, lettuce, and tomato. Add cooked ground beef to pizza dough with cheese, then bake and top with lettuce and tomato.
  43. Chili and cornbread: Spicy chili and crumbled cornbread. Make by spreading chili on pizza dough, adding crumbled cornbread and cheese, then baking.
  44. Pretzels and beer cheese: Soft pretzel pieces and beer cheese sauce. Make by placing pretzel pieces on pizza dough with cheese, then baking and drizzling with beer cheese sauce.
  45. Nutella and strawberries: Hazelnut chocolate spread and fresh strawberries. Make by spreading Nutella on pizza dough, adding sliced strawberries, and baking.
  46. Gummy bears and whipped cream: Colorful gummy bears and whipped cream. Make by baking pizza dough with cheese, then topping it with gummy bears and a dollop of whipped cream.
  47. Pine nuts and arugula: Toasted pine nuts and fresh, peppery arugula. Make by adding pine nuts to pizza dough with cheese, baking, and topping with fresh arugula.
  48. Gyros and tzatziki sauce: Seasoned meat and cool, creamy tzatziki. Make by adding cooked gyro meat to pizza dough with cheese, baking, and topping with a dollop of tzatziki sauce.
  49. Anchovies and caponata: Salty anchovies and sweet-sour Sicilian eggplant dish. Make by adding anchovies and prepared caponata to pizza dough with cheese, then baking.
  50. Edible flowers and honey: Colorful edible flowers and sweet honey drizzle. Make by baking pizza dough with cheese, then topping it with edible flowers and drizzling it with honey.
  51. French fries and gravy: Crispy French fries and savory gravy. Add cooked French fries to pizza dough with cheese, bake it, and drizzle with warm gravy.
  52. Baklava-inspired pizza: Phyllo dough, honey, and crushed nuts. Make by placing layers of phyllo dough on pizza dough, adding crushed nuts, and baking, then drizzling with honey.
  53. Ramen noodles and soy sauce: Cooked ramen noodles and savory soy sauce. Add cooked ramen noodles to pizza dough with cheese, baking, and drizzle with soy sauce.
  54. Chorizo and plantains: Spicy Spanish sausage and sweet, fried plantains. Make by adding cooked chorizo and fried plantain slices to pizza dough with cheese, then baking.
  55. Seafood Mix: Japanese pizza places often serve seafood pizzas with toppings like squid, octopus, and eel.
  56. Frog Legs: In France, frog legs have hopped onto pizzas, offering a mild flavor reminiscent of chicken.
  57. Camel Milk Cheese: In North African countries like Morocco, camel milk cheese is a unique, local alternative to traditional cheese.
  58. Caviar: While it may seem luxurious, caviar-topped pizza can be found in upscale restaurants in places like New York and Moscow.
  59. Coconut: In Costa Rica, shredded coconut is often used as a topping to give pizza a tropical spin.
  60. Pickles: Particularly in the Midwest of the United States, dill pickle pizza is a surprising hit, offering a tangy twist on the traditional pie.

The Psychology Behind Trying New Foods

Embracing unusual pizza toppings isn’t just about culinary adventure; it reflects our willingness to challenge our comfort zones and step into the unknown. Humans are naturally creatures of habit, often sticking to what is familiar and comforting. However, new experiences, including trying new foods, can stimulate our senses, trigger curiosity, and even increase our enjoyment of eating.

From a Psychology perspective, our willingness to try new and unusual pizza toppings can also indicate our openness to new experiences, a trait linked with personal growth, creativity, and a generally more positive outlook on life.

For many, the thrill of culinary exploration is an essential part of the dining experience. Trying an unexpected pizza topping can spark a sense of adventure and novelty, providing a break from the routine and even leading to new favorite flavors.

The excitement of the unfamiliar can also create memorable experiences, whether you’re sharing a laugh over a durian pizza or reminiscing about the time you tried a slice topped with alligator meat.

Moreover, venturing beyond traditional pizza toppings can open our minds to different cultures. It invites us to appreciate the diversity of global cuisines and understand the regional ingredients and culinary traditions that shape each unique pizza creation.

This exploration can foster a sense of connection and empathy with people worldwide, showing us that food is a universal language that transcends borders.

Ultimately, while some may balk at the idea of unconventional pizza toppings, it’s an exciting culinary journey for others. It’s about more than just the taste—it’s about the stories, the cultures, and the experiences that come with every bite.

So, the next time you see a pizza topped with something you’ve never heard of, take a leap of faith. Who knows, you might just discover a new favorite.

Recipe Ideas for Adventurous Pizza Eaters

For those who fancy a culinary adventure at home, here are some unique pizza recipes that you might want to try. While some ingredients may seem eccentric, don’t be too quick to judge — these pizzas may surprise you with their delightful flavors.

  • Alligator Sausage Pizza: Start with your usual pizza dough, spread a generous amount of tomato sauce, sprinkle mozzarella cheese, then add alligator sausage slices (available online or in specialty stores). Bake until golden and crisp. Garnish with fresh basil before serving.
  • Sweet and Spicy Banana Curry Pizza: Lay out your pizza base, and add a layer of curry-infused tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, slices of banana, and a sprinkle of curry powder. Bake until the cheese is bubbly and slightly browned.
  • Seafood Pizza, Japanese Style: Cover your pizza dough with a mixture of soy sauce and tomato paste for an umami-packed base. Top with mixed seafood (shrimps, squid, and eel), thinly sliced bell peppers, and a mix of mozzarella and nori (seaweed) strips. Bake until perfection and enjoy a taste of Japan at home.
  • Brazilian Green Peas Pizza: Begin with a pizza base, spread a good amount of tomato sauce, add generous amounts of mozzarella, then scatter green peas on top. You can add ham or bacon for added flavor. Bake until the cheese is melty and delicious.
  • Australian Exotic Meat Pizza: This pizza could be an interesting try if you can source kangaroo or emu meat. Add tomato sauce, cheese, and your exotic meat of choice to prep your pizza base. Sprinkle some native Australian bush spices for a more authentic taste. Cook until everything is nicely done.
  • Moroccan Spiced Lamb Pizza: For a taste of North Africa, spread your pizza dough with a thin layer of hummus. Top with ground lamb, pre-cooked with Moroccan spices (think cumin, coriander, and cinnamon), and crumbled feta cheese. Bake until crisp and golden, then sprinkle with fresh mint and squeeze lemon juice before serving.

Remember, the psychology behind trying these unique recipes lies in the adventure – the thrill of creating something out-of-the-box and the possibility of discovering an unexpected new favorite. Happy pizza experimenting!

Ooni Promo

The Role of Creativity and Experimentation in the Pizza Culinary World

Pushing the Boundaries of Traditional Cuisine

Creativity and experimentation are the lifeblood of the culinary world. Without them, we’d still be eating the same dishes our ancestors ate centuries ago, bereft of the culinary variety and excitement we now enjoy.

Much like in art or science, pushing the boundaries in cooking involves taking risks, challenging conventions, and daring to tread where others haven’t. Unusual pizza toppings are a perfect example of this boundary-pushing spirit, transforming the familiar into the extraordinary and creating a gastronomic experience that goes beyond the norm.

These strange toppings do more than just shock or surprise — they make us reevaluate our preconceptions of what pizza should be. They expand our understanding of what’s possible in pizza making and, by extension, in cooking as a whole. This fearless spirit of experimentation keeps the culinary world vibrant, continually evolving, and full of surprises.

Innovation and Cultural Exchange

Creativity in the kitchen isn’t merely about novelty; it’s a vital catalyst for innovation and cultural exchange. Every time a chef decides to top a pizza with something unexpected, they’re not just creating a new dish; they’re potentially sparking a new food trend, inventing a new flavor combination, or introducing consumers to an ingredient they may not have encountered otherwise.

Furthermore, as pizza has spread around the globe, each culture has added its unique spin, creating a mosaic of pizzas that reflect the world’s diversity. Whether it’s a sushi pizza in Japan or a haggis pizza in Scotland, these creations are a testament to our shared love for this dish, despite our geographical and cultural differences.

Such innovation fosters an atmosphere of learning and exchange, where culinary traditions can be shared, appreciated, and evolved. It creates a global culinary dialogue that enriches our food experiences, broadens our tastes, and brings us closer together. In this way, the act of crafting an unconventional pizza becomes a beautiful symbol of culinary creativity and cultural unity.

The Last Slice

In its wonderfully adaptable form, pizza is a testament to our collective culinary creativity and adventurous spirit. As we’ve journeyed from the traditional Italian base of tomatoes and cheese to a global smorgasbord of unusual and unique toppings, it’s clear that the humble pizza is more than just a meal — it’s a canvas for innovation and cultural expression.

These daring and weirdest pizza toppings challenge our palates and preconceptions, encouraging us to embrace different flavors, ingredients, and culinary traditions. They remind us of the joy of discovery, the thrill of experimentation, and the boundless potential of food as a medium for connection and exploration.

Whether you’re a fan of the traditional or have a penchant for the peculiar, the world of pizza offers something for everyone. So why not step outside your comfort zone? You never know — your new favorite topping might just be a slice away.

Bon appétit!

Enjoy!

Not a PRO? Not a Problem!

Take a pizza class to bring your pizza skills to the next level,

so you can be a PRO!

Baker's Percentage Charts for Pizza

Baker’s Percentage Charts for Pizza Dough: Unlock the Secret Formula for Perfect Pizzas Every Time!

the PROs

This baker’s percentage chart will give you a starting point to develop your own recipe.  These are the four main base recipes that can be adapted to any other pizza style. 

Costco Pizza Prices

Costco Pizza Price 2023 (Best Bang for Your Buck!)

the PROs

Costco Pizza Price 2023 Costco Pizza is one of the best options for finding delicious and affordable pizza. Its large …

how to mix pizza dough

How to Mix Pizza Dough

the PROs

How to Mix Pizza Dough Do you want to learn how to mix pizza dough? Pizza dough is a staple …

Check Out Our Pizza T-Shirts

Check Out Our Preferred Vendors

Newsletter

Subscribe to our Recipe of the Week newsletter and receive our partners’ latest recipes, tips, and discount offers.

Keep in Touch!

info@homemadepizzapro.com

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Table of Contents