What is the Number 1 Pizza in America? The Quest for the Ultimate Slice

By: the PROs

What is the Number 1 Pizza in America? The Quest for the Ultimate Slice

What is the number 1 pizza in America?

This question has sparked debates and friendly arguments around nationwide dinner tables and pizza joints. The answer might surprise you, or perhaps, it’s exactly what you expected. Either way, the love for pizza unites us all, and the answer to this tantalizing question lies just ahead.

In this post, we will take a flavorful journey through the diverse landscape of American pizza styles and uncover the true champion of them all. We’ll explore the criteria that make a pizza truly exceptional and divulge the best of the best.

So, whether you’re a die-hard pizza aficionado or simply curious, we invite you to grab a slice, settle in, and continue reading to learn more about America’s ultimate pizza obsession.

Let’s get started!

Key Takeaways

What is the Number 1 Pizza in America?

New York-style pizza reigns supreme as America’s number 1 pizza, thanks to its iconic thin, foldable slice and the perfect balance of crust, sauce, and cheese.

The diverse range of pizza styles in America, including Chicago-style deep-dish, Detroit-style, and California-style pizzas, highlights the creativity and passion of American pizza makers.

The ongoing debate about the best pizza style is a testament to the unifying love for pizza nationwide and the personal preferences that make each pizza experience unique.

Embarking on a pizza adventure and exploring different styles is a delicious way to celebrate the diverse flavors and textures that have made pizza an enduring culinary treasure in America.

Pizza Popularity in America

Ah, pizza! It’s hard to find someone who doesn’t have a soft spot for this universally loved dish. Pizza has been warmly embraced in America, becoming a staple of our culinary culture. With so many pizza joints, chains, and mom-and-pop shops spread across the country, you’re never too far from a delicious pie.

In fact, according to the National Association of Pizzeria Operators (NAPO), it’s estimated that a staggering 3 billion pizzas are sold in the U.S. each year!

Clearly, your love for pizza is shared by millions of others.

Diversity of Pizza Styles

As you travel across America, you’ll notice that each region has its own unique spin on pizza. From the thin, foldable slices of New York-style to the deep, hearty goodness of Chicago-style deep dish, there’s no shortage of variety. You might also come across Detroit-style pizza with its crispy, cheesy edges or the adventurous toppings and fresh ingredients found in California-style pies.

The Neapolitan-style pizza also harks back to pizza’s Italian origins with its simple yet sophisticated flavors. The diversity of pizza styles across the country is a testament to the creativity and passion of American pizza makers.

Our Quest to Identify the Number 1 Pizza in America

Given the incredible range of pizza styles, you might wonder, “What is the number 1 pizza in America?” It’s a question that many have attempted to answer, leading to countless pizza taste tests, competitions, and even scientific studies.

As you dive deeper into the world of pizza, you’ll find that opinions can be fiercely divided. But don’t worry, that’s all part of the fun! The quest to identify America’s top pizza is a delicious adventure, and by the end of this post, you’ll have a definitive answer.

As we embark on our quest to discover the number 1 pizza in America, let’s take a moment to explore the various pizza styles that grace our nation. Each one has its own unique characteristics, and while they all share the common bond of being pizza, they offer delightfully distinct experiences for your taste buds.

Pizza Styles

New York-style pizza

Originating in the Big Apple, New York-style pizza is famous for its thin, foldable slices. Its crispy, slightly chewy crust is perfect for on-the-go eating. The toppings are typically simple, often featuring a classic combination of tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and your favorite meats or veggies. A quintessential New York slice is something every pizza lover should experience at least once.

Chicago-style pizza (deep-dish)

Venture to the Windy City and discover the hearty, indulgent world of Chicago-style deep-dish pizza. With its thick crust, generous layers of cheese, and rich tomato sauce, this pizza is more like a savory pie. It’s perfect for those who enjoy a hearty meal and aren’t afraid to get a little messy while digging in.

Detroit-style pizza

Hailing from the Motor City, Detroit-style pizza boasts a thick, rectangular crust that’s crisp on the outside and light and fluffy on the inside. The cheese is spread all the way to the edges, creating a mouthwatering caramelized crust. Toppings are usually placed beneath the cheese, and the pizza is finished with a generous drizzle of tomato sauce on top.

California-style pizza

California-style pizza is a must-try for those who crave something a little different. Known for its innovative toppings and gourmet ingredients, this pizza style is inspired by the Golden State’s fresh, diverse flavors. Expect unique combinations like goat cheese, arugula, barbecue chicken, and cilantro, all atop a thin, crispy crust.

Neapolitan-style pizza

Last but not least, we have Neapolitan-style pizza, which pays homage to pizza’s Italian roots. These pies are made with simple, high-quality ingredients, a thin, slightly charred crust, and a delicate balance of flavors. San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and fragrant basil come together in perfect harmony to create a pizza that’s as elegant as it is delicious.

Now that we’ve explored the different pizza styles, it’s time to delve deeper into the criteria that will help us determine the number 1 pizza in America. Are you ready to discover which style takes the crown?

Criteria for Evaluating the Best Pizza

As we get closer to revealing the number 1 pizza in America, it’s important to consider the criteria that set the best pizzas apart from the rest. These factors influence our personal preferences and contribute to a pizza’s widespread appeal and iconic status.

Let’s break down the essential criteria for evaluating the best pizza:

Taste and flavor

When it comes to pizza, taste is king. The harmony of flavors created by the combination of sauce, cheese, and toppings plays a crucial role in determining a pizza’s greatness. A well-balanced flavor profile, with just the right amount of seasoning and spices, is essential for a truly unforgettable pizza experience.

Texture and crust

The crust is the foundation of any great pizza; its texture can make or break the entire pie. Whether you prefer a thin and crispy crust or a thick and doughy one, the perfect pizza crust should be able to hold its own against the flavors and weight of the toppings without becoming soggy or falling apart.

Toppings and ingredients

A pizza’s toppings and ingredients are the stars of the show. The best pizzas feature fresh, high-quality ingredients that enhance the overall flavor and presentation of the pie. From the classic pepperoni and cheese to more adventurous options, the right toppings can elevate a pizza to new heights.

Popularity and customer satisfaction

While personal preferences can vary, the best pizzas tend to have a broad appeal and consistently satisfy customers. Popularity is often an indicator of a pizza’s quality, as people keep coming back for more. Customer satisfaction is key, and a pizza that delights the masses has a strong case for being the best.

Iconic status and cultural impact

The number 1 pizza in America should be delicious and have a lasting impact on our culinary culture. Iconic pizzas are more than just a tasty meal; they represent a particular region, inspire other pizza makers, and influence the evolution of pizza as a whole.

With these criteria in mind, we can now delve into the great debate and determine which pizza style truly deserves the title of America’s number 1 pizza. Get ready to discover the ultimate pizza champion!

The Number 1 Pizza in America: New York-style Pizza

Ladies and gentlemen, the moment you’ve all been waiting for has arrived. After considering the various styles and evaluating them based on our criteria, we proudly announce that the number 1 pizza in America is the iconic New York-style pizza!

A survey conducted by YouGov in 2018 found that New York-style pizza was ranked as the most popular pizza style in the United States, with 38% of respondents preferring it over other styles like Chicago-style deep dish (23%) and Sicilian-style pizza (12%).

Let’s take a closer look at why this classic pizza has captured our hearts and taste buds.

New York Pizza

The iconic thin, foldable slice

The New York-style pizza is famous for its large, thin, and foldable slices. Its versatility makes it perfect for a quick, on-the-go meal or a relaxed dinner with friends. This iconic slice has become synonymous with the American pizza experience and is beloved by people from all walks of life.

The perfect balance of crust, sauce, and cheese

One of the secrets to the New York-style pizza’s success is its impeccable balance of flavors and textures. The thin, slightly chewy crust provides a sturdy foundation for the tangy tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella cheese. Each bite is a delightful harmony of taste and texture, making it nearly impossible to resist.

Ubiquitous presence and influence across the nation

The influence of New York-style pizza extends far beyond the city that never sleeps. Its presence can be felt in pizzerias nationwide as countless pizza makers strive to replicate that perfect New York slice. Its widespread popularity is a testament to its exceptional taste and universal appeal.

The importance of the New York pizza scene

New York City is home to some of the world’s most famous and revered pizzerias, such as Lombardi’s, Di Fara, and Joe’s Pizza. The city’s pizza scene is legendary, and it’s no surprise that many consider it to be the ultimate pizza destination. The success of New York-style pizza is intrinsically linked to the city’s vibrant and competitive pizza scene, where only the best slices can rise to the top.

So there you have it! The New York-style pizza reigns supreme as America’s number 1 pizza. While this may spark some friendly debates among pizza enthusiasts, one thing is certain: the love for pizza brings us all together, and New York-style pizza holds a special place in the hearts of millions.

Honorable Mentions

While New York-style pizza has claimed the title of America’s number 1 pizza, it’s important to acknowledge the incredible variety and innovation found in other pizza styles. These honorable mentions may not have taken the top spot, but they still hold a special place in the hearts and stomachs of pizza lovers nationwide.

Chicago-style deep-dish pizza

A far cry from the thin slices of New York, Chicago-style deep-dish pizza is a hearty, filling, and indulgent experience. With its thick crust and generous layers of cheese and tomato sauce, this pizza is like a meal in itself. Although it may not be everyone’s go-to choice for a quick bite, the deep-dish pizza has a dedicated following, and its comfort-food appeal has earned it a place among America’s most beloved pizzas.

Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
Chicago-style deep-dish pizza

Detroit-style pizza

Detroit-style pizza may not be as well-known as its New York and Chicago counterparts, but it has a unique charm all its own. The thick, rectangular crust with crispy, caramelized edges makes for an irresistible texture, while the creative placement of toppings beneath the cheese adds a delightful twist. Detroit-style pizza has been gaining popularity in recent years, and it’s certainly worth trying if you haven’t already.

Detroit pizza
Detroit-style pizza

California-style pizza

Last but not least, we have innovative and adventurous California-style pizza. Known for its unique gourmet toppings and fresh ingredients, this pizza style embodies the spirit of California cuisine. While it may not be as deeply rooted in tradition as other pizza styles, its willingness to push boundaries and experiment with new flavor combinations has earned it a dedicated fan base. If you’re in the mood for something a little different, California-style pizza is a delicious and exciting choice.

California-style pizza

Although these honorable mentions didn’t quite make it to the top, they each bring something special to the table. The diversity of American pizza styles is a testament to our shared love for this iconic dish, and there’s no better way to celebrate that love than by exploring and enjoying all the different varieties.

The Last Slice

The quest to identify the number 1 pizza in America is a delicious and engaging journey filled with personal preferences and friendly debates. While our exploration has crowned New York-style pizza as the ultimate champion, it’s important to remember that the beauty of pizza lies in its diversity and the unique experiences each style brings to the table.

The unifying love for pizza across America is a testament to its enduring appeal and the countless memories shared over a hot, cheesy pie. Regardless of whether you agree with our choice or have a different favorite, we can all agree that pizza is a culinary treasure that has captured our hearts and taste buds.

As we celebrate the New York-style pizza victory, we encourage you to explore different pizza styles and discover the unique flavors and textures they offer. Whether it’s a classic New York slice, a hearty Chicago deep-dish, or an innovative California pie, each pizza has its own story to tell.

So, go ahead and embark on your own pizza adventure, and remember, the best pizza is always the one you enjoy the most!

What is Brooklyn Style Pizza

What is Brooklyn Style Pizza? A Journey from the Streets of New York to Your Kitchen

the PROs

What is Brooklyn Style Pizza? This query is more than just a question about a pizza style. It’s an invitation …

9 pizza styles

9 Mouthwatering Pizza Styles You Can Easily Make at Home

the PROs

Today, we’ll walk you through 9 pizza styles you can make at home to help you improve your pizza-baking skills.  …

Hydration Percentage by Pizza Style

7 Hydration Percentages by Pizza Style that Actually Make the Best Pizza

the PROs

Making a pizza is all about getting your pizza dough to have just the right amount of hydration. If you’re looking to get the best results this guide can help you find the specific pizza dough hydration according to your desired pizza style.  Let’s check it out!

Doughball Weight by Pizza Size

Pizza Dough Weight Chart: The Ultimate Cheatsheet by Pizza Style

the PROs

Most of us know that we should be weighing our ingredients for the best accuracy and consistency in baking. The same principle goes for pizza dough! So if you would like to know how much dough you need for your pizza, jump right in! Don’t forget your FREE PDF!

Sicilian Pizza Style

Sicilian Style Pizza Recipe

the PROs

Continuing our line of base recipes that you can adapt to any pizza style; we present a totally different style. Our recipe is a variation of the authentic Sicilian pizza, prepared in a manner that originated in Sicily, Italy.

New York-Style Pizza Recipe

Easy Homemade New York-Style Pizza Recipe

the PROs

This Homemade New York Style pizza recipe will literally transport you to NYC’s corner pizza joint where you get a humongous pizza slice that is dripping in its remarkable flavor.


Not a PRO? Not a Problem!

Take a pizza class to bring your pizza skills to the next level,

so you can be a PRO!

Costco Pizza Delivery

Costco Pizza Delivery: Find How You Can Get It Now!

the PROs

People go to Costco’s food court for many different reasons, but the cheesy slice of pizza they serve is among …

Pizza for Beginners: Don’t Buy Pizza, Make It! Here’s How to Get Started!

the PROs

You have this idea that you want to make pizza at home as opposed to ordering it, but where do you start? Don’t worry! Here you will find answers and directions to all your questions.

Pizza toppings under cheese or over

Pizza Toppings Under Cheese or Over Cheese? [Why the Order Matters]

the PROs

Is Pizza Cheese on Top or Bottom? Hey pizza lovers, are you wondering if you should layer pizza toppings under …


Subscribe to our Recipe of the Week newsletter and receive our partners’ latest recipes, tips, and discount offers.

Keep in Touch!


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.